The regret rate is for life-changing surgery, a 20% regret rate, regret after gender-affirming surgery: a multidisciplinary rate. The regret rate for gender-affirming surgery is less than 1%. A systematic review of patients' regret after surgery What do you think of the study that states less than 1%? More results from www, reddit, com. After selecting the articles, we evaluated the characteristics of the study.
We identified the year of publication, the country in which the study was conducted, the size of the population and the number of transmale and transfemale patients with their respective average age (expressed with SD, rank or interquartile range if were included in the study). In addition, we extracted information about the data collection method (interviews versus questionnaires), the number of regrets after GAS, as well as the type of surgery, follow-up time and transition procedures. We classified the type of regret based on the patient's reasons for regret if they were mentioned in the studies. The Pfäfflin, Kuiper and Cohen-Kettenis regret classifications were used (Table 1).
There is an unknown percentage of transgender and gender-unconfirmed individuals who undergo gender-affirming surgery (GAS) who experience regret. These authors defined the expression “regret” as a patient who returns to the clinic after surgery to access hormones that could reverse their gender transition (and who notes this fact in their history). The causes and types of regrets reported in the studies are specified and shown in tables 55 and 6.The inclusion criteria were all articles that included patients aged 13 years or older who underwent GAS and who reported regret or transition rates, and observational or intervention studies in English or Spanish. A recent systematic review and meta-analysis, a type of study in which the authors grouped many articles into one large estimate that, combined, found an overall 1 percent regret rate after surgery for both transmasculine and transfeminine surgeries.
A controlled vocabulary supplemented with keywords was used to search for studies on transition and regret in adult patients who underwent gender confirmation surgery. The lowest estimate I've seen of regret after receiving gender-related care is based primarily on people who have undergone gender-affirming surgery. Some arguments in favor of laws that restrict gender-affirming care claim that patients may one day regret any irreversible or semi-irreversible part of their transition, but a small new study found that satisfaction with such surgery is significant, even in the long term. Regret can cause physical and mental morbidity and calls into question the appropriateness of these procedures in some patients.
Subgroup analysis of the prevalence of regret among people with TGNB after gender-based gender confirmation surgery. Special attention should be paid to identifying and recognizing the prevalence and factors associated with regret. In general, the follow-up time from surgery to the time of evaluation of regret ranged from 0.8 to 9 years (Table 2).
